Leave this siteLeave site
BtBFAMILY DISPUTE RESOLUTION

Beyond the Binary / Research-informed practice development

FAMILIES

Family Assessment of Maltreatment, Impact, Lived Experience, Intersectionality, Engagement and Safety

Beyond identifying risk. Towards understanding harm.

Family separation is not experienced as a series of isolated incidents. Its consequences may be cumulative, developmental and relational, shaping children's daily functioning, protective responses, access to support and the freedom with which adults can negotiate.

Original BtB framework · professional practice and education initiative

Why FAMILIES came to be

FAMILIES grew from a recurring tension at the intersection of family violence scholarship, frontline practice and family law: the information most readily documented in separation disputes is not always the information that best explains how a family is functioning, how harm has accumulated or what a child is experiencing. A well-organised chronology can obscure the context of a relationship; an apparently uncooperative response can reflect protective adaptation; a child’s distress may be attributed to one parent without sufficient developmental enquiry. Conversely, no single behaviour or presentation should be treated as conclusive evidence of coercive control or trauma.

The challenge is not a lack of existing screening instruments. Tools such as Family Law DOORS make important contributions to risk identification and whole-of-family enquiry. Rather, FAMILIES is being developed to address the subsequent task of formulation: how an FDR practitioner integrates competing accounts, patterns over time, developmental and relational impacts, structural disadvantage, participation conditions and the risks created by the proposed dispute resolution process itself.

Its purpose is to make this reasoning more explicit, reflective and accountable. It is not a claim that every family requires the same assessment, that every conflict is coercive control, or that an FDR practitioner should become an investigator or diagnostician.


Impartiality does not require indifference

An FDR practitioner can remain impartial between participants without being neutral about conditions that compromise safety, autonomy or meaningful participation.

Family Dispute Resolution requires independence and impartiality. Those commitments must not be confused with assuming that all parties have equivalent power, freedom, resources or exposure to harm. The professional task is neither to take sides nor to erase difference. It is to examine the conditions under which each person is being asked to participate, including whether they can disagree, understand, make decisions and negotiate without undue influence or fear of consequences.

This distinction is consistent with the statutory framework. Section 20 of the Family Law (Family Dispute Resolution Practitioners) Regulations 2025 requires an accredited practitioner to determine whether FDR is appropriate before and during sessions, having regard to family violence, safety, bargaining power, child abuse risk, health, undue influence and other matters materially affecting free negotiation. Section 22 requires the process, as far as possible, to be suited to participants’ needs. The Attorney-General’s Department describes practitioners as independent and neutral, but neutrality is not a direction to disregard the context that the law requires practitioners to assess.

FAMILIES takes that obligation seriously. It treats contextual awareness, critical self-reflection and attention to children’s lived experiences as compatible with impartial practice, not departures from it.


The practice problem

In complex separation matters, a child’s school refusal may be described as resistance, anxiety, disability-related distress or evidence of parental influence. Repeated requests for information may be experienced as responsible co-parenting or as surveillance. Reluctance to negotiate may reflect inflexibility, fear of repercussions, inaccessible communication, exhaustion or a history of coercive control. None of these explanations can responsibly be adopted from presentation alone.

FAMILIES approaches such matters through disciplined enquiry rather than premature categorisation. It asks practitioners to consider chronology, patterns of conduct, impacts on family functioning, alternative explanations and the conditions needed for safe, informed and meaningful participation. It is particularly attentive to the possibility that protective responses may be misread as obstruction, while also recognising that not every disagreement, disability-related difficulty or adverse outcome is evidence of abuse.


An integrated, developmentally attentive approach

The framework organises professional reasoning around eight connected areas: behavioural patterns and responsibility; cumulative harm and functioning; children’s lived experiences and developmental significance; relationships, care and protective adaptation; intersectional and structural conditions; engagement, autonomy and bargaining power; safety and prospective exposure; and the effects of the FDR process itself.

Its distinctive emphasis is contextual formulation: bringing together what is reported, what can be corroborated, what is disputed, what remains unknown and what may change the suitability decision. The aim is not to diagnose trauma, make forensic findings or assign a numerical prediction of future harm.

Children’s developmental experiences

Children may communicate distress through behaviour, withdrawal, somatic complaints, changes in sleep, attendance, regulation or relationships. These experiences require careful attention without treating any one presentation as proof of a particular cause. Developmental stage, disability, neurodivergence, attachment relationships, exposure to conflict or violence, and the child’s wider circumstances may all be relevant. Children's expressed experiences should be considered through appropriate, safe and developmentally responsive processes, not inferred solely from adult accounts.

Coercive control, adaptation and accountability

An incident-focused account can obscure patterns in which intimidation, economic restriction, monitoring, litigation-related pressure or repeated demands accumulate over time. FAMILIES encourages enquiry into the function and effect of behaviour, including what happens when a person disagrees or sets a boundary. It distinguishes the use of power from responses to constrained choices, without assuming a finding of perpetration before the evidence supports one.

Disability, neurodivergence and communication

Differences in communication, executive functioning, sensory processing, memory or emotional expression must not be mistaken for unreliability, hostility or incapacity. Equally, accessibility adjustments alone do not resolve coercion or unequal bargaining power. Practitioners must assess both the accessibility of the process and the freedom of each person to participate without undue influence.

Kinship, culture and family diversity

Family relationships may extend beyond a two-parent legal model. FAMILIES considers Aboriginal kinship and connection to Country, extended and chosen families, LGBTQIA+ and multi-parent family structures, migration and language, financial insecurity and the effects of institutional systems. Culturally responsive practice requires enquiry into the particular family and its own relationships, not assumptions drawn from identity. Legal status, caregiving reality and relational significance may not align neatly.


The FDR process is part of the assessment

A proposed parenting application, shared document, meeting format, invitation, support person or communication rule can alter the balance of power or expose a participant to new risks. A shuttle process is not automatically safe; an online process is not automatically accessible. FAMILIES therefore examines not only the family’s circumstances but also the possible consequences of the intervention itself.

This aligns with the continuing duty under section 20 of the Family Law (Family Dispute Resolution Practitioners) Regulations 2025 to determine whether FDR sessions are appropriate, including consideration of family violence, safety, bargaining power, child abuse risk, health, undue influence and other matters materially affecting free negotiation. Section 22 addresses tailoring the process to participants’ needs. FAMILIES does not replace these statutory duties; it is being developed to support transparent professional reasoning in their application.


Research foundations and professional boundaries

FAMILIES draws on established bodies of scholarship and practice, including family violence and coercive control research, children’s exposure to domestic and family violence, trauma-informed and developmentally responsive practice, and family-law screening and assessment. Australian tools such as Family Law DOORS already address whole-of-family risk, including child development and wellbeing. FAMILIES does not claim to have invented contextual assessment or to supersede validated instruments. Its proposed contribution is to integrate longitudinal harm, developmental and relational functioning, meaningful participation and process consequences within an explicit FDR suitability formulation.

The framework is in development and requires independent critique, practitioner piloting and systematic evaluation. It is not yet a validated screening instrument, psychometric scale, diagnostic tool, predictive model or accredited qualification. It must not be used to replace specialist risk assessment, legal advice, safeguarding duties or independent professional judgement.

Selected evidence and legislative sources


Scholarship, lived experience and the practice behind FAMILIES

Kellene Elder is the founder of Beyond the Binary Family Mediation Services (BtB), an accredited Family Dispute Resolution Practitioner and a Master of Domestic and Family Violence Practice graduate of CQUniversity. Her master's research examined the experiences of LGBTQIA+ survivors of domestic and family violence within family court processes, including the consequences of institutional responses and the ways in which safety, identity and unequal power may be understood or overlooked in family law.

Her postgraduate education also encompasses domestic and family violence practice, counselling and the facilitation of men’s behaviour change, alongside specialist training in coercive control, child safety, the Safe & Together Model and protective behaviours. Her professional experience spans family violence practice, safeguarding, governance and complex family systems.

FAMILIES emerges from the intersection of postgraduate scholarship, specialist practice and lived understanding of the complexity of family separation and institutional processes. At BtB, lived experience informs the questions asked and the commitment to accessibility and accountability; it does not replace evidence, independent assessment or professional boundaries.

BtB’s approach is grounded in the recognition that no two families experience separation in the same way. It is inclusive of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander families, LGBTQIA+ and sistergirl and brotherboy communities, neurodivergent and disabled people, culturally and linguistically diverse families, multi-parent and polyamorous family structures, and families whose relationships are not fully captured by conventional legal categories.


Acknowledgement of Country and commitment to accountability

Beyond the Binary Family Mediation Services acknowledges the Whadjuk Noongar people as the Traditional Custodians of the Boodjar on which our practice is based. We pay respect to Elders past and present, and recognise the continuing authority of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, their cultures, kinship systems and connections to Country.

We acknowledge the profound and continuing harms of colonisation, including the Stolen Generations, forced child removal and the ongoing over-representation of Aboriginal children in out-of-home care. We recognise that these are not simply historical matters and that family law and helping professions have responsibilities to examine the impacts of institutional power, racism and dispossession.

Always was, always will be Aboriginal land.

Lived experience, inclusion and professional integrity

BtB recognises lived experience as an important source of knowledge about how systems are encountered, navigated and experienced, particularly where disability, family violence, identity, trauma or marginalisation shape access to justice. Our commitment is to bring this understanding into dialogue with research, statutory obligations, critical reflection and culturally responsive, trauma-informed practice.

We approach people with dignity, without presuming that safety, consent, bargaining power or family relationships can be inferred from outward presentation. No participant should have to disclose personal trauma or identity to receive respectful, accessible and considered service.